top of page
Writer's pictureRachael Camp (ANutr, RD)

Why Do People Go to Extremes in Diet and Lifestyle? A Guide to Finding Balance



In today’s world of quick fixes, viral trends, and rigid rules, it’s easy to see why so many of us feel pressured to take extreme measures when it comes to diet and lifestyle. Whether it’s cutting out entire food groups, following an ultra-restrictive eating plan, or overcommitting to intense workout regimens, many find themselves in a cycle of “all or nothing.” But why do we feel this pull toward the extremes? And, more importantly, how can we break free and build a healthier, more balanced approach?


Let’s dive into the story behind extreme behaviors and how you can be the hero of your own journey toward sustainable wellness.


The All-or-Nothing Mindset


The all-or-nothing mindset thrives on perfection. It convinces us that we must follow a plan to the letter, leaving no room for flexibility or errors. Why? Because extremes feel simple. Cutting out carbs completely? Easy to follow (at least initially). Working out every single day? Clear instructions. But the truth is, these extremes often set us up for failure and guilt when we can’t keep up.


The villain feeds on our desire for control, especially when life feels chaotic. It whispers that extremes will give us fast results or make us “in control” of our health. But in reality, it traps us in cycles of burnout, frustration, and even harm.


Understanding Why We Gravitate to Extremes


To take back control of your story, it helps to understand why extremes are so alluring:


  1. Quick Fix Mentality: We live in a world that values speed. Extreme diets or fitness programs promise rapid transformations the type of changes we can’t wait to show off. But quick fixes rarely last.

  2. Social Media Influence: Platforms highlight the most dramatic transformations and diets, leaving us feeling like moderation isn’t enough. Who hasn’t scrolled through a feed and felt tempted by a success story that seems too good to be true?

  3. Fear and Misinformation: Fear-based messaging around food and health drives people to eliminate things unnecessarily, leading to imbalanced diets.

  4. Validation and Identity: For many, extremes become part of their identity. “I’m keto.” “I’m paleo.” Following a strict plan can feel like a badge of honor, earning praise from others while masking unsustainable habits.


Finding Balance and Building a Sustainable Story

Here’s where you step into the hero’s role. The good news is that you don’t need to go to extremes to achieve your goals. Instead, you can write a new narrative that prioritises long-term wellness over quick, unsustainable wins.


Here are five steps to take control of your story:


  1. Recognise the Villain: Acknowledge when the all-or-nothing mindset is taking over. Ask yourself: Am I doing this because it feels good and sustainable, or because I’m chasing fast results?

  2. Focus on Progress, Not Perfection: Shift your mindset to celebrate small, consistent wins rather than dramatic changes. Eating one balanced meal a day is better than none. Taking a walk twice a week is better than burning out after seven days straight at the gym.

  3. Stay Grounded in Facts: Misinformation can be powerful, so arm yourself with knowledge. Learn to distinguish between trends and evidence-based practices. Consult reliable sources or professionals for guidance.

  4. Create an Enjoyable Routine: The most effective diet or exercise plan is the one you enjoy and can stick to. Start small: incorporate foods you love, move in ways that feel good, and allow room for flexibility.

  5. Embrace Moderation as Strength: Remember, balance is not a weakness. It’s the key to long-term success. Moderation allows you to enjoy life while still working toward your goals no burnout, no guilt. NOTE: Moderation can be challenging for many, which might explain why the allure of extremes often feels more attainable and appealing.


Write a New Chapter


The story of extremes doesn’t have to define you. Instead, choose a narrative of balance, progress, and self-compassion. You don’t need to eliminate entire food groups or follow rigid rules to feel successful. What matters most is consistency, flexibility, and finding joy in the journey.


If you’ve been stuck in cycles of extremes, consider this your invitation to rewrite your story. Small, sustainable changes are the real hero’s journey—and it’s one you’re fully capable of conquering.




4 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page